Hsu Tzu-chiang Case

Hsu Tzu-chiang Case

Hsu Tzu-chiang was convicted and sentenced to death seven times and to life imprisonment twice for allegedly being involved in a kidnapping and extortion case. The courts based their guilty verdicts primarily on the confessions of his co-defendants. However, these co-defendants' confessions not only contradicted one another, but each individual's statements were also inconsistent over time. Can evidence like this truly justify a guilty verdict?

Left only with co-defendants who "pointed the finger at him," Hsu Tzu-chiang, who was innocent and trusted the justice system, decided to face the charges head-on. Little did he know that what awaited him was an endless path of injustice.

"For over a decade, I always wanted to hug my mother."

Reflecting on his life "inside," Hsu Tzu-chiang said this.

Sixteen years on death row, twenty years of litigation, and a persistent injustice every step of the way—boundless despair was once what awaited Hsu Tzu-chiang. We still do not understand what it takes for the judicial system to admit its mistakes. Yet, on the road to justice, with every additional person who stands up, perhaps we can walk one less mile of wrongful suffering.

Learn about the Hsu Case

05Nov.
2015

Let Love Flow and End Wrongful Convictions: Premiere of the Music Video "Daisê kah To-siā" in Support of Hsu Tzu-chiang

Judicial Reform Foundation

This music video for the song "Daisê kah To-siā" (Sorry and Thank You) began when lead vocalist SUZUKA casually asked…

05Nov.
2015

Let Love Flow and End Wrongful Convictions: Premiere of the Music Video "Daisê kah To-siā" in Support of Hsu Tzu-Chiang

Judicial Reform Foundation

This music video for the song "Daisê kah To-siā" (Sorry and Thank You) began when lead vocalist SUZUKA casually asked…

30Sep.
2015

To Appeal or Not: The Prosecutor-General Must Take a Stand — Press Conference Calling on the Prosecutor-General to Forego Appeal in the Hsu Tzu-chiang Case

Judicial Reform Foundation

After the Taiwan High Court rendered a not-guilty verdict in the ninth retrial of the Hsu Tzu-chiang case on September…

20Sep.
2015

Between Judicial Independence and Accountability in the Hsuch Tzu-chiang Case

Kao Jung-chih / Executive Director, Judicial Reform Foundation

"The original judgment is set aside. Hsuch Tzu-chiang is not guilty." As Presiding Judge Hsieh Ching-heng uttered these…

07Sep.
2015

Hsu Tzi-chiang is a Philosopher

Kao Jung-chih / Executive Director, Judicial Reform Foundation

Psychologists say that facing devastating disasters brings extreme trauma. The emotional force of trauma is too…

07Sep.
2015

Hsu Tzu-chiang and Cheng Hsing-tse

Ch'ien Chien-jung / Judge, Taoyuan District Court

Looking at the final judgment in the Cheng Hsing-tse case, the court did not even dare to explicitly state that the…

03Sep.
2015

Justice Blooms, Saluting Three Brave Judges

Lin Yu-sheng / JRF Volunteer, Executive Secretary of the Taiwan Association for Innocence

After a 20-year legal battle, the Hsu Tzu-chiang case—which went through 7 death sentences, 2 life sentences, 1…

03Sep.
2015

Twenty Years of Presumption of "Guilt"

Chen Yu-fan / Deputy Executive Director, Judicial Reform Foundation

The High Court, in the ninth remand retrial, acquitted Hsu Tzu-chiang, with the sole rationale being the "presumption…

01Sep.
2015

Innocence Without Fear, Justice Arrives Late: Celebrating Twenty Years of Judicial Reform – Statement on the Not-Guilty Verdict of Hsu Tzu-chiang's 9th Remand Trial

Judicial Reform Foundation

At 11:00 AM this morning, judges Hsieh Ching-huan, Lin I-hsiu, and Wu Tso-cheng of the Taiwan High Court panel…

27Aug.
2015

Melodies of the Heart: The 'Hsu Tzu-chiang is Innocent' Benefit Concert

Judicial Reform Foundation

Ahead of the ruling on Wednesday, September 1, Hsu Tzu-chiang is experiencing tense and complex emotions. A group of…

18Aug.
2015

Waiting 20 Years: Hoping for Justice to Arrive and Hsu Tze-Chiang's Innocence

Cheng Meng-shan / Third-year student, Department of Political Science, Soochow University

The ninth retrial of the Hsu Tze-chiang case will deliver its verdict at 11:00 AM on September 1. Summer interns at the…

12Aug.
2015

Judges, Please Stop Asking About Your Senior Colleagues' Opinions!

Text by Chen Hsin-yi (Junior, Department of Law, Providence University); Illustrations by Hsu Yan-wen

During my summer internship at the Judicial Reform Foundation, I attended several sessions of the Hsu Tzu-chiang…