2016 Judicial Reform for All Movement
2016 Citizen Judicial Reform Movement
In 2016, the Judicial Reform Foundation launched the largest citizen-participatory judicial reform campaign in Taiwan's history. Through online voting, cross-island cycling, and public evaluation meetings, we gathered the public's authentic perceptions of judicial problems, analyzed their causes, and formulated solutions. This effort sought to establish a bottom-up, citizen-driven model for judicial reform and laid an important foundation for the subsequent National Congress on Judicial Reform.
Movement Background
Following the political transition in 2016, public expectations for judicial reform reached an unprecedented high, serving as a critical window of opportunity to advance reform.
For a long time, public dissatisfaction with the judiciary in Taiwan continued to accumulate. Every time a controversial judgment of major significance occurred, public opinion would boil over, only to eventually subside into helpless sighs. The Judicial Reform Foundation realized that merely responding passively to individual cases could not truly drive systematic reform. Transforming public sentiment into concrete directions for reform was the core question addressed by this movement.
The "Citizen Judicial Reform Movement" advanced through three stages: "Identifying Problems → Analyzing Causes → Proposing Solutions." It attempted to anchor reform in grassroots problems and introduced both legal and non-legal professionals to jointly evaluate them, breaking the habit of legal professionals talking only among themselves.
Established an online platform inviting the public to propose and vote on the judicial problems they felt most urgently needed resolution. Concurrently, a cross-island cycling tour was undertaken to visit courts across Taiwan and listen to local voices.
Convened an evaluation panel consisting of judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys, scholars, and individuals from non-legal backgrounds to conduct multi-perspective causal analyses of the judicial problems voted on by the public, with non-legal professionals making up more than half of the panel.
Proposed solutions one by one for each problem's cause, evaluated their pros and cons alongside execution difficulties, and hosted the "Judicial Reform Knock Knock" seminar series to promote and discuss them deeply within various communities.
Although this movement did not run its full course because its schedule later overlapped with the official National Congress on Judicial Reform and resources were limited, its innovative model of citizen participation, its focus on the quality of police interrogation, and its role as a benchmark for comparison during the 2017 National Congress on Judicial Reform left a profound and lasting impact.
Pre-launch Phase: Expectations and Demands for the New Government
Amidst the political transition in May 2016, the Judicial Reform Foundation publicly presented judicial reform demands to the new president and ignited the atmosphere for reform discussions through commentary articles.
Stage 1: Gathering Problems──Public Voting and Cross-Island Cycling
In May 2016, the movement officially launched. The Judicial Reform Foundation established an online voting platform and simultaneously initiated the "Cross-Island Cycling Tour: Express Delivery of Local Judicial Reform Opinions" campaign, visiting courts across Taiwan over 13 days to deliver grassroots voices directly to the Presidential Office.
Stage 2: Analyzing Causes──Multi-Perspective Evaluation
From June to July 2016, experts from legal and non-legal backgrounds were invited to convene two evaluation meetings to conduct causal analyses on problems voted on by the public, with the entire process broadcasted live.
Stage 3: Finding Solutions──Seminar Series and Annual Results
In the second half of 2016, the Judicial Reform Foundation held the "Judicial Reform Knock Knock" seminar series, entering various communities to promote discussions, and consolidated the whole year's movement results at the end of the year.
2016 Citizen Judicial Reform Movement Annual Special Issue
Synthesizing the results of the whole year's movement, including public-voted problems, causal analysis reports, cycling tour records, and concrete recommendations for judicial reform, this is the most complete documentary record of this citizen movement.
Publication Date: 2016-10-01 ｜ Judicial Reform Foundation
Follow-up Impact: Becoming a Benchmark for Comparison for the National Congress on Judicial Reform
In 2017, the official National Congress on Judicial Reform was convened. Using the results of the 2016 Citizen Judicial Reform Movement as a yardstick, the Judicial Reform Foundation continuously tracked and monitored whether reform commitments were being implemented.
Judicial Reform Never Stops
The 2016 Citizen Judicial Reform Movement pioneered a new model of citizen participation in judicial reform. In 2017, the National Congress on Judicial Reform took over the baton, but whether the reform commitments will be implemented still relies on continued civil monitoring.
2017 Judicial Reform Resolutions: Monitoring and Implementation 1999 National Conference on Judicial Reform
2016
Blind Spots and Perspectives in Offense of Favoritism Cases: From the Distinction Between Practical Logic and Scientific Logic
Judges who have long engaged in legal practice are unlikely to have the time to read literature related to the social…
2016
Cycling Around Taiwan: Starting from the Justice Problems of the Most Vulnerable! - Press Release on the Taoyuan District Court Event
As the first stop of the cycling tour around Taiwan, the team departed from the Taoyuan District Court on May 13 at…
2016
National Judicial Reform Movement, Ready, Set, Go! Cycling Around Taiwan to Deliver Local Judicial Reform Opinions
We believe the root cause lies in failing to properly ask the people from the very beginning: What is wrong with the…
2016
Reforming the Judiciary Starts with Asking the Right Questions: Press Conference on the Launch of the National Judicial Reform Movement
Today marks the launch press conference of the "National Judicial Reform Movement," unveiling its campaign website…
2016
Press Conference Urging President Tsai Ing-wen to Fulfill Her Judicial Reform Platform: A New Vision for "Presidential Political Energy in Judicial Reform"
Tsai Ing-wen promised to convene a "National Judicial Reform Conference" after being elected, explicitly stating in the…
2016
Please! Can a Judicial Reform "Conference" Really Be Held Like This?
There are numerous issues in judicial reform, and most stakeholders may not be internet users. If the internet-using…
2015
The New President's Soft Target—Judicial Reform
Looking ahead to the 2016 presidential election, the candidates boil down to just a few familiar faces. Regardless of…